Guest mode · Progress saved in this browser only. Clearing browsing data removes it. Optional ChatGPT sign-in saves a separate record across devices.
Rubric practice
Put the response under the lens
Apply a rubric. Give credit for what works, and identify what does not.
For appropriateness, content flags and user-satisfaction ratings, use the full response-comparison rubric.
Exercise 01 / 16
A useful answer with a missing condition
Prompt
Using only this fictional return policy, answer in two sentences: can I return an opened item? Policy: “Opened items can be returned within 14 days if faulty. Non-faulty opened items cannot be returned.”
AI response
You can return an opened item within 14 days. Keep your receipt and contact the shop.
Your assessment
Rate each criterion from 1 to 5.
Rating anchors
1 — major failure · 2 — significant issues · 3 — mixed · 4 — minor issue · 5 — fully meets criterion.
Rubric agreement measures distance from the reference ratings; it is not a factual accuracy test.
1 — major failure · 2 — significant issues · 3 — mixed · 4 — minor issue · 5 — fully meets criterion.
Rubric agreement measures distance from the reference ratings; it is not a factual accuracy test.
50%
UnsureVery confident
In two or three sentences, point to a specific part of the response, explain how it meets or misses the request, and say what remains uncertain. Give credit for what works too.